Time, Indifference, and Long-Term Pre-removal Immigration Detention

Open Access
Authors
Publication date August 2025
Journal European Public Law
Volume | Issue number 31 | 3
Pages (from-to) 421-442
Organisations
  • Faculty of Law (FdR)
Abstract
This article gives a philosophical account of how and why public authorities employ time in the context of long-term pre-removal immigration detention (LPID) in Europe. Existing philosophical accounts see immigration detention as an expression of sovereign power, disciplinary power or governmentality. Most persuasive is the paradigm of detainability (De Genova). This article finds that the existing philosophical accounts can capture aptly most forms of migrant detention and areas of migration policy (e.g., asylum detention, hotspots, and the border detention regimes at the fringes of Europe), but not LPID in Europe. An alternative logic can better explain how and why authorities deploy LPID: indifference. Authorities simply do not care about the migrant’s time. They are indifferent and think they can afford to be indifferent, because the problem is politically, legally, and logistically irrelevant. A practical upshot of the findings in this article relates to modes of resistance. If LPID is not a matter of disciplinary power and governmentality, then the corresponding modes to resist disciplinary power and governmentality are unavailable or obsolete. By contrast, if LPID is better understood in terms of indifference, resistance may come from an unexpected source, namely individual officials acting by stealth.
Document type Article
Language English
Published at
https://doi.org/10.54648/euro2025019 (Final published version)
Downloads
EURO2025019 (Final published version)
Permalink to this page
Back